Blog

A jar of apple butter lying on red apples

Our Favorite Recipes for Cooking with Apple Butter

September 11, 2025  |  Carter Mountain Orchard

Category: Food & Recipes  |  Tags: apples, recipes

Apple butter is a beloved fall pantry staple. You can find multiple varieties in our Country Store and available for ordering online, or make it yourself from fresh-picked apples. However you get your hands on it, there’s plenty of delicious ways to use it!

What is apple butter, and how is it different from apple sauce?

Both apple sauce and apple butter are made from a combination of apples, sugar, and spices: the main difference is cooking time and consistency. Apple sauce becomes apple butter if allowed to simmer for a longer time, until it forms a thick spread with a buttery texture. Generally, apple sauce can be eaten on its own, while apple butter is best used as a topping or ingredient in another dish.

There are so many ways to use apple butter!

Cinnamon apple sauce made by Chiles Family Orchards

Apple butter is a flavorful spread

Apple butter is an easy go-to spread with a sweet, concentrated apple flavor. Here are some of our favorite ways to use apple butter straight from the jar:

  • Swirl into ice cream for a hint of cinnamon
  • Spread on biscuits, pancakes, toast, or scones for breakfast
  • Frost cupcakes or pumpkin bread
  • Mix into mashed sweet potatoes
  • Top ham sandwiches or turkey paninis

Recipes with Apple butter for entrees, sides, and dessert

Pork chops primavera

Entrees

Apple butter is an easy glaze or marinade for most meats and is particularly well-suited to pork and poultry.

Chicken apple meatballs

Snacks and Sides

Transform apple butter into a savory-sweet sauce, mix it into vegetables, or spread it on crostini for a punch of apple-y goodness.

Apple butter banana bread

Desserts and Breakfast

Kick the apple flavor up a notch by incorporating apple butter into your favorite fall baked goods and sweet treats.

Bonus: Apple Butter Cocktails

Yes, you can even drink apple butter! These cocktails add autumnal delight to any gathering:

Autumn apple bourbon fizz.
Apple butter old fashioned

When making apple butter from scratch, not apples are created equal!

Read our apple flavor profile guide to select the best apples for making apple butter at home and see when each apple variety is in season.